When we purchased Wildling, I didn’t order a spinnaker because I wasn’t sure if we would need one, and if we did, what type and size we should get. I’m glad I waited, because now that we have sailed our boat for a year, I have a better idea of what I want a spinnaker to do for us. So this month I went through the process of selecting our spinnaker.
Although Robin and I have sailed many miles with a spinnaker on our Catana 471, I really enjoyed learning more about spinnaker design during this process, and I thought I would share some of that information in this post. I would like to thank Jean-Pierre at Outremer (designer, test pilot, and catamaran guru), Nick at Doyle Sails UK, and Volker (who’s 5X is now under construction and will be launched later this year) for sharing their experience and advice.
First a bit of theory: When sailing to a downwind destination in a catamaran, particularly a fast one, we really want to sail on a reach (90-130 degrees AWA), because it’s much faster than sailing deep downwind. Once the angle starts to get more than 130, things begin to slow down to a point where at 150-160, a reaching sail isn’t much use. On a performance boat, as we sail higher (further towards the wind), the boat accelerates and the apparent wind angle moves further forward, which makes sailing a reach very effective, and even though it might be at an angle to the destination, requiring us to travel further by gybing back and forth to stay on course, the extra speed means it’s still the fastest way to get there.
On a technical note: this technique of creating apparent wind is what allows true performance catamarans to move the apparent wind forward of the beam and create speeds well in excess of the true wind speed. take a look at the Americas Cup multihulls that sail at boat speeds close to 40 knots for a demonstration of this.
So every boat should have a downwind reaching sail, which for us, is our Delta Voiles, Code-D gennaker, and you would think that since reaching is the fastest way to get downwind, then that’s the only downwind power sail you need! Well, perhaps… if you’re a racing sailor, then yes, reaching is the way to go. But it takes a lot more work and attention from the crew. You have to trim the angles just right, compensate for wind shifts and watch things carefully. But when cruising, our objectives are different to a racing sailor. What we want is low-stress, comfortable, and fast enough.
So what’s fast enough? I’m sure this is different for everybody, but on Wildling, our target speed range is 9-12 knots. If we’re under 9, I’m working to get us more speed, either by sailing different angles, changing sails, or dialing in the trim. If we’re over 12, then I’m going to start reducing sail to slow us down. There’s no extra benefit to us from sailing a reach and doing a bunch of gybing if we could go fast enough, and more comfortably, on a direct course.
We’re going to be sailing Wildling back home to Australia, a voyage that involves may thousands of miles downwind in the tradewinds, that are often blowing at 15 to 25 knots. It would be ideal if we could turn the boat downwind, set our sails for our “fast enough” speed and not have to constantly mess with the sail trim. That’s where the spinnaker comes in. With a spinnaker, we can sail deeper downwind angles than the limit of our Code-D. But which type of spinnaker should we buy?
There are two types of spinnaker: asymmetric and symmetric, with the asymmetric being the most common spinnaker on a cruising catamaran. Asymmetrics are more like a gennaker, in that they have a different length luff, and leech, but they have a lot more curve in the luff than a gennaker, which allows the luff to twist around to windward and generate power at a deeper angle. They are good for deep reaching, usually up to about 150 degrees, and they can get deeper still if the tack is moved to the windward hull. They’re good because they are versatile, and if you don’t have a gennaker, and want only one downwind power sail, then the asymmetric is the way to go. There are a couple of problems with running deep angles on an asymmetric though. Running deep is not their optimum power zone, and in order to gybe, you have to first douse the sail, move the tack to the other bow, gybe the boat and then rehoist the sail. Some folks rig a system of lines to move the position of the tack between the bows, which saves some of the work when gybing, but depending on the amount of wind, it’s usually safest to douse the sail and rehoist.
Since we have a Code-D, we’re looking for our spinnaker to fill in the 140 to 180 degree angle range, and that is the domain of the symmetric spinnaker. Symmetrics are made to run deep, and gybing is essentially automatic, because they just float around the front of the boat onto the new point of sail, with a few tweaks on the control lines. No need to douse and rehoist.
We decided to get a symmetric spinnaker for Wildling, so the next step was to figure out the size, cut and type of sailcloth for the sail. For our tradewind ocean sailing we want to be able to handle situations where the wind builds more quickly than we expected, and we don’t want the spinnaker to tear if it gets hit by a 25 knot gust. We also don’t want it so big that we can’t get it down in a breeze.
There are many excellent sailmakers that can make a great spinnaker. We chose Doyle sails, mainly because I’ve used their sails before and know they are well made, and Doyle was willing to listen and understand our needs and design a specific sail that will work for our boat and our cruising plans. They are making us a symmetric spinnaker with a fairly wide and deep cut in the top section of the sail which will allow it to lift and fly out in front of our mainsail. We sized the spinnaker to be 30% smaller than our sail plan specifies with a heavier 1.5oz fabric that will handle 25+ knots of breeze. This should give us a strong sail that will hold it’s shape well and be fairly easy to control and douse with a spinnaker sock.
It’s also worth mentioning that there is another symmetric sail that is becoming more common, and that’s the Parasailor. It’s essentially a symmetric spinnaker with a parafoil wing in the center. The wing provides some lift and also can spill the power from gusts. It’s a great idea, but we decided against this sail for two reasons: It’s more difficult to get the sock down over the parafoil wing in stronger winds; and we know of another 5X that tried the sail and found it didn’t work very well. The 5X has a lot of acceleration and it tended to collapse the sail too much when they sped up on waves (although it seems that could be solved by experimenting with the size of the sail).
We don’t have the all the deck fittings and control lines needed to fly a symmetric spinnaker on Wildling, so now that the sail is ordered, the next project is to prepare the boat to be able to use it.
9 thoughts on “Fun with Spinnakers”
Looking forward to see the result! I am as well considering to improve my sail wardrobe as well, and it will be interesting to get your experience on the result when it is on Wildling and has been tested. When are you getting your new spinnaker? Please post some info on the Outremer Owners site on Facebook as well.
Hi Knut, The spi should be done by July 10th, I’ll keep you posted for sure.
Hi Doug all ever hear is good about the Parasailor spinnaker, where some folks have left it up for weeks crossing the atlantic..
Hi Ivan, I’ve heard lots of good things too, I’m just a bit nervous about a parasailor on a boat this size. Our sailplan specifies 260sq meters of spinnaker. We downsized it to 200m2 but it’s still a very big sail for just Robin and I to handle alone.
HI Doug, thank you for sharing this information. Your experiences and insights are awesome and helpful. Couple of questions on your choice of the combo of the Code D and Symmetrical. For a heavier Cat do you feel that a different combination would be better. For example a Code 0 in lieu of the Code D and possibly using both a symmetrical and asymmetrical? Or skipping the asymmetrical for a Code 0 and symmetrical? Also, how have you set up the spin halyards on your boat, are they lead aft or are they at the mast base? How many have your rigged? For the running rigging on the symmetrical, do you plan to have both down hauls on the bows and spin sheets? Thanks in advance for your thoughts here.
For a heavier catamaran, the main issue is that it’s hard to get the boat moving in light winds, which means you have to motor more than on a lighter boat. This makes gennaker selection perhaps even even more important than on a performance cat. So, for sure you need a code-0 which will give you much more power in light conditions upwind. We have a code-0 on Wildling which we use for upwind angles between 40 and 90 degrees. It’s like a supercharger in light air, and I would recommend every catamaran owner has a code-0 in their inventory. The code-0 won’t help you much downwind, but the best solution for downwind angles depends on how you like to sail. If you don’t want to mess with a lot of headsail changes, then I would get a cruising asymmetric spinnaker, like the Doyle APC. With this, you can fill in all the sailing angles from 90 degrees down to 140 when tacked to the bowsprit and down to about 170 if you tack to the windward bow. If you want to optimize performance in all downwind angles, then a setup like I described on Wildling with a downwind gennaker (like a code-D) and a symmetric spinnaker is the way to go, but this configuration does require more sail changes. If we get lazy, I might try and push the code-0 a bit further downwind to see what it can do for us, and maybe skip having to switch to the code-D, and go directly to the symmetric. It won’t be as fast, but it might be “fast enough”.
Regarding the rigging for the symmetric. We will be putting a standup block on each bow to run the guys back to the helm station winches, and then the spinnaker sheets will run back to our gennaker sheet winches in the cockpit, so there will be 4 lines to control the symmetric. The gennaker/spinnaker halyards are led to the mast base and from there we lead them to either the winch at the mast base, or we can direct them back to the electric winch at the helm station. I normally use the electric winch as it saves a lot of work when hoisting.
Thanks Doug, good insight.
Thanks so much Doug great insite.
Great info Doug. We are also in the decision making process regarding down wind sails for ROAM. Looking forward to hearing your thoughts once you have made some miles on the Symetric vs the Code D. Saw Moana at Musket Cove the other day. Awesome boat.